{ "entity_a": { "slug": "applebot-extended", "name": "Applebot-Extended" }, "entity_b": { "slug": "bingbot", "name": "Bingbot" }, "fields_documented": 13, "claims": 19, "last_verified": "2026-09-14", "fields": [ { "field": "cites_sources", "value_a": null, "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 127, "same": false }, { "field": "follows_noarchive", "value_a": null, "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 131, "same": false }, { "field": "honours_crawl_delay", "value_a": "n/a", "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": 2, "claim_id_b": 122, "same": false }, { "field": "opt_out_mechanism", "value_a": null, "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 130, "same": false }, { "field": "publishes_ip_list", "value_a": "no", "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": 3, "claim_id_b": 123, "same": false }, { "field": "purpose_documented", "value_a": "policy_only", "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": 5, "claim_id_b": 125, "same": false }, { "field": "reads_llms_txt", "value_a": null, "value_b": "not_documented", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 128, "same": false }, { "field": "respects_robots_txt", "value_a": "n/a", "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": 1, "claim_id_b": 121, "same": false }, { "field": "robots_token_differs_from_ua", "value_a": "yes", "value_b": null, "claim_id_a": 8, "claim_id_b": null, "same": false }, { "field": "separate_search_and_training_tokens", "value_a": "yes", "value_b": "no", "claim_id_a": 6, "claim_id_b": 126, "same": false }, { "field": "user_agent_string_full", "value_a": null, "value_b": "Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; bingbot/2.0; +http://www.bing.com/bingbot.htm)", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 129, "same": false }, { "field": "verifiable_by_rdns", "value_a": "n/a", "value_b": "yes", "claim_id_a": 4, "claim_id_b": 124, "same": false }, { "field": "what_it_controls", "value_a": "AI training use of content, not search indexing", "value_b": null, "claim_id_a": 7, "claim_id_b": null, "same": false } ], "differences": [ { "field": "cites_sources", "statement_a": null, "statement_b": "Copilot Search in Bing delivers clearly cited sources alongside generative answers to support publishers and content owners.", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 127 }, { "field": "follows_noarchive", "statement_a": null, "statement_b": "Bingbot excludes noarchive-tagged content from Copilot and Chat answers and from generative AI training data.", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 131 }, { "field": "honours_crawl_delay", "statement_a": "Apple does not publish a Crawl-delay behaviour for Applebot-Extended.", "statement_b": "Microsoft states that a crawl-delay directive in robots.txt always takes precedence over Bing Webmaster Tools crawl control settings for Bingbot.", "claim_id_a": 2, "claim_id_b": 122 }, { "field": "opt_out_mechanism", "statement_a": null, "statement_b": "Microsoft lets publishers block Bingbot content from Copilot answers and AI training using noarchive and nocache tags.", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 130 }, { "field": "publishes_ip_list", "statement_a": "Apple publishes no IP list specific to Applebot-Extended and documents one shared crawl identity for Applebot.", "statement_b": "Microsoft publishes Bingbot's IP address ranges as a JSON file at bing.com/toolbox/bingbot.json for verification purposes.", "claim_id_a": 3, "claim_id_b": 123 }, { "field": "purpose_documented", "statement_a": "Applebot-Extended controls whether website content is used to train Apple general purpose foundation models.", "statement_b": "Bingbot serves as Microsoft's standard crawler and handles most of Bing's daily web crawling.", "claim_id_a": 5, "claim_id_b": 125 }, { "field": "reads_llms_txt", "statement_a": null, "statement_b": "Microsoft does not publish whether Bingbot reads llms.txt files.", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 128 }, { "field": "respects_robots_txt", "statement_a": "Applebot-Extended is a robots.txt token that publishers disallow to opt out of generative model training.", "statement_b": "Bingbot honors robots.txt directives and other Microsoft-supported control mechanisms that content owners set for crawling.", "claim_id_a": 1, "claim_id_b": 121 }, { "field": "robots_token_differs_from_ua", "statement_a": "Applebot-Extended is a robots.txt control token and does not correspond to a separate crawler user agent string.", "statement_b": null, "claim_id_a": 8, "claim_id_b": null }, { "field": "separate_search_and_training_tokens", "statement_a": "Webpages that disallow Applebot-Extended remain eligible for inclusion in Apple search results.", "statement_b": "Microsoft controls Bingbot's use in AI training through meta tags rather than publishing a separate training-specific crawler token.", "claim_id_a": 6, "claim_id_b": 126 }, { "field": "user_agent_string_full", "statement_a": null, "statement_b": "Bingbot sends a user agent string containing bingbot/2.0 and a link to Microsoft's bingbot.htm page.", "claim_id_a": null, "claim_id_b": 129 }, { "field": "verifiable_by_rdns", "statement_a": "Apple does not publish a reverse-DNS verification method specific to Applebot-Extended.", "statement_b": "Microsoft verifies Bingbot traffic through reverse DNS lookups that resolve to hostnames ending in search.msn.com.", "claim_id_a": 4, "claim_id_b": 124 }, { "field": "what_it_controls", "statement_a": "Applebot-Extended controls the AI training use of crawled content and does not control search indexing.", "statement_b": null, "claim_id_a": 7, "claim_id_b": null } ], "sources": [ "https://blogs.bing.com/search/April-2025/Introducing-Copilot-Search-in-Bing", "https://support.apple.com/en-us/119829", "https://www.bing.com/toolbox/bingbot.json", "https://www.bing.com/webmasters/help/ai-performance-9f8e7d6c", "https://www.bing.com/webmasters/help/crawl-control-55a30303", "https://www.bing.com/webmasters/help/how-to-verify-bingbot-3905dc26", "https://www.bing.com/webmasters/help/robots-meta-tags-and-attributes-that-bing-supports-5198d240", "https://www.bing.com/webmasters/help/which-crawlers-does-bing-use-8c184ec0" ] }